Stop Shooting at Synagogues
Friday March 13, 2026 – כ״ד אֲדָר תשפ”ו
Dear World,
Please stop shooting at synagogues and taking your anger out on the Jews. Thank you.
In the past week alone, five synagogues have been targeted in attacks, including yesterday’s assault on Temple Israel in West Bloomfield, outside Detroit. Jewish communities across the country are shaken, frightened, and exhausted. Once again, we find ourselves repeating a basic plea that should not have to be said in the twenty-first century: Jewish houses of worship are not legitimate targets for anyone’s anger, grievance, or political protest.
If you have an issue with the Israeli government, that is legitimate—depending on what your issue is (as in critiquing Israel’s policies or its existence). Democracies invite debate, criticism, and disagreement. But ramming your car into a synagogue preschool or opening fire near a Jewish community will not bring back relatives lost in Lebanon. It will not change Israeli policy. And it will not be seen as meaningful protest or legitimate policy critique. It is antisemitism, plain and simple.
Temple Israel in West Bloomfield has no sway over what Benjamin Netanyahu and the Israeli government decide to do in prosecuting a war. Nor does it control the decisions of the United States government in the Middle East. The families who pray there, send their children to preschool there, and gather there for holidays and life-cycle moments are simply American Jews living their lives.
When anger at the Israeli government becomes violence directed at Jews in suburban Detroit, the world is not witnessing political protest—it is witnessing antisemitism.
And the Jewish community is tired of having to explain this over and over again.
I recently asked my daughter’s high school principal—an intelligent, thoughtful, and caring educator—how he would react if students of Chinese descent were blamed and ridiculed for the policies of the Chinese government, or if students with Russian-sounding names were harassed because of Vladimir Putin’s war against Ukraine. He was appalled by the thought. Then he paused and said quietly, “Oh, I see.”
Thankfully, he affirmed that no student should ever be singled out because of their religion, ethnicity, or heritage. No one should have to hide who they are because of geopolitical events thousands of miles away.
That principle should apply to Jews as well.
Yet the reality of Jewish life today tells a different story. As an Israeli, I am conditioned to sit in restaurants and cafés, quietly keeping an eye on the door and noticing who enters. As a Jew in America, I sit pray in synagogue on Shabbat aware that we have undergone active shooter training. I know where the exits are. I look around the room, notice the elderly woman with a walker, and wonder how I would help her if something terrible were to happen. I glance at the children and imagine how we would protect them if—God forbid—the unthinkable occurred.
As a parent, I worry that the next shooting could take place at my children’s school. As a member of a Jewish day school board, we spend countless hours each year fundraising not for scholarships, programs, or teachers, but for security. There’s no question that preparation is key to preventing tragedies. Rabbi Marla Hornsten of Temple Israel in West Bloomfield, MI, commented to me, “This is the thing that we had all prepared for and prayed that it would never happen, and then it did, and thank God that security was well prepared and that no one was hurt.”
My own synagogue recently installed a sophisticated metal detection system at the entrance. It is technology that the many churches in our neighborhood simply do not need. I do not resent them for that—in fact, I pray they never will need it. But the reality is that Jewish institutions must now spend enormous resources simply to protect themselves.
Just imagine what Jewish communities—and society as a whole—could accomplish and contribute if those resources, personnel, and hours of vigilance were devoted instead to education, service, and community building.
Israel today spends an enormous share of its national resources on defense—well over five percent of its entire economy, one of the highest defense burdens of any developed country in the world. Much of that spending is necessary to defend its citizens from real threats posed by Iran and the network of armed groups it supports across the region. But every shekel devoted to missiles, interceptors, and fortifications is a shekel that cannot be invested in schools, housing, healthcare, or the social fabric of Israeli society. Imagine what Israel—and the entire region—could build if those resources were not consumed by the constant need for defense.
The truth is that antisemitism is not new. The modern Zionist movement emerged in part as a response to what was once called the “Jewish Question.” Theodor Herzl believed that the creation of a Jewish state would normalize Jewish existence. If Jews had a nation like every other nation, he believed, we would finally be accepted among the family of nations.
Others were less optimistic. Ze’ev Jabotinsky believed that hatred of Jews would not simply disappear. In his view, Jewish sovereignty was not only about national revival—it was about survival, about ensuring that the Jewish people would have the strength to defend themselves in the face of recurring hostility.
American Jews once believed that the promise of the American dream might offer another answer. In the great melting pot, Jews would assimilate, become fully American, and leave behind the old hatreds of Europe. Jews rose to remarkable levels of success and influence in American life—far beyond what our small numbers might predict.
And yet, here we are.
Today antisemitism is again rising from multiple directions. It appears on the far right and on the far left. It manifests as conspiracy theories about Jewish power, and as ideological rejection of Jewish nationalism. It appears in vandalism, harassment, and increasingly, in violence.
Part of the tragedy is that hatred of Jews has always been fueled by the same dangerous myths—that Jews are uniquely powerful, disloyal, or responsible for the world’s problems—and today those ancient conspiracies often merge with modern political anger at Israel. The Iranian regime has elevated this hatred into state ideology, openly denying Israel’s right to exist and repeatedly declaring that the “Zionist regime” must be eliminated, a position rooted in the revolutionary ideology that emerged after Iran’s 1979 Islamic Revolution and continues to shape its regional strategy today.
None of this is new to Jewish history.
On Purim we read how Haman described the Jewish people to the Persian king:
יֶשְׁנוֹ עַם־אֶחָד מְפֻזָּר וּמְפֹרָד בֵּין הָעַמִּים… וְדָתֵיהֶם שֹׁנוֹת מִכָּל עָם
“There is a certain people scattered and dispersed among the nations… whose laws are different from those of every other people.” (Esther 3:8)
Difference itself became the accusation.
And on Passover we sing the haunting words of the Haggadah:
שֶׁלֹּא אֶחָד בִּלְבָד עָמַד עָלֵינוּ לְכַלּוֹתֵנוּ, אֶלָּא שֶׁבְּכָל דּוֹר וָדוֹר עוֹמְדִים עָלֵינוּ לְכַלּוֹתֵנוּ
“Not only one has risen against us to destroy us, but in every generation there are those who rise against us.”
These words are not meant to instill despair. They are meant to remind us that hatred of Jews has appeared in many forms throughout history—and that Jewish survival has required resilience, solidarity, and moral clarity.
But when anger at the Israeli government turns into violence against Jews in Detroit, Pittsburgh, Los Angeles, or anywhere else, it ceases to be a political protest. It becomes antisemitism.
Criticize Israel where warranted. I do, all the time. Debate its policies. Protest its government.
Democracies invite that. But know that your words and slogans are not just words or catchy chants. They are being taken to heart and translated into action. So choose them carefully.
Targeting Jews—our synagogues, our schools, our children—is not activism. It is hatred.
And it must stop.
Because a synagogue is not a battlefield. A preschool is not a proxy for geopolitics. And Jews—wherever we live—are not responsible for the decisions of a government thousands of miles away. In fact, targeting Jews only diverts attention away from the actual issues, unifies us, and prevents further empathy for the cause you claim to promote.
The world must finally learn this basic truth: attacking Jews will not bring justice to anyone. It will only repeat one of humanity’s oldest and most shameful patterns.
Enough.

